Tuesday, 9 June 2015

On the joys of not using Powerpoint


 

It has been said by others that Powerpoint has 'neither power, nor point', and in some respects I am inclined to agree.  Therefore this week I have been taking up @teachertoolkit 's challenge to show myself as a resilient teacher by not using Powerpoint for a week.

I'm on day two now and I feel like I'm having withdrawal symptoms.  Other colleagues have remarked on how 'brave' I am, and some students seem dumbstruck when I tell them that I am going PPT 'cold turkey'.

So, what I've been asking myself is, how did we get into this state of affairs? I left secondary school in 1998, and Sixth Form in 2000, and I don't recall having a single PPT shown to me in all that time, yet I don't feel that my education missed out on it.  Students have been taught a variety of subjects for thousands of years without the benefit of Powerpoint, producing intellectuals who it is very difficult for us mere mortals to rival.

Therefore, at what point did it become the educational orthodoxy that every lesson had to have a Powerpoint attached to it as standard?  Presumably at some point between me leaving Sixth form and starting my PGCE training in 2008. Can anyone enlighten me?

Having to cope without a PPT certainly reveals how reliant I had become on it, even just in terms of putting on something from BBC class clips while I gave out hand outs.  Today I taught a lesson on Stalingrad, which I always enjoy teaching,  and usually I go through a few slides to give students the context.  However, as this wasn't an option today we used the relevant section from 'Peace and war' instead to give them the context.  I often don't use 'Peace and war' as I find it pitched a little too high for many students, but it made me consider how I myself have made myself part of the problem by 'dumbing down' the context via PPT, giving them a summary rather than allowing them to read it for themselves.

Having no PPT instead forces one to rely on tried and tested tactics such as reading textbooks, asking questions, and coming up with activities such as role play.

Some of the feedback we had from a recent HMI inspection was that our kids are rather too passive.  It makes me wonder whether we haven't helped to create this situation by boring kids to death with endless Powerpoint presentations!

Friday, 5 June 2015

New Key Stage 3?

So like many of you,  we've been scratching our heads over how to prepare for the new History GCSE (at least for OCR), which is mostly thematic, unlike the way we've taught History since I trained in 2008.

Initially I severely disliked the idea of thematic teaching, thinking that it would lead to gaping black holes in students knowledge, with little 'islands' of knowledge (i.e. The Tudors) surrounded by the modern equivalent of 'Here be dragons'.  However,  I've come to realise that the reality is this happens anyway through chronological teaching, where students seem to forget almost everything they've learned from year to year.

Recently I've been very influenced by the work of Brown, Roediger et al in their work 'Make it stick' , which I was introduced to after attending the training for the Cambridge PGCE mentors.  My understanding of their work is that the only way we can hope to get students to remember anything is by continually revisiting  and interweaving topics so that we can reinforce those pesky neural pathways that lead to long-term learning, which isn't what happens with conventional history teaching, where we teaching something like the 'Black Death', assess it afterwards, and then never return to it again.

Therefore, with this in mind, I read TH 130 and Ian Dawson's article entitled 'Thinking across time: Planning and teaching the story of power and democracy at Key Stage 3', which I found very inspiring, particularly Dawson urging us to ask ourselves about... 'each topic.. ‘if you’re never going to refer back to this later in Key Stage 3, why are you doing it at all?’

Instead, Dawson argues that we should try to create common themes across different years that enable students to tell a coherent 'story' at the end of Key Stage 3, for example in his version the story of power and democracy.

Using his ideas as a starting point, I've mocked up a draft scheme of work for next year.  I've also tried to use elements of Michael Fordham's work (see his excellent blog ), in which he argues that progress over time can't be assessed in individual topics, but instead only by assessing not only that entire year's learning, but also in Year 8 going back over Year 7 stuff etc. I've stolen Dawson's idea of making a video at the end of each unit which they can watch, reflect on, and laugh at how much they've grown in the preceding year.

My colleague Alan Carpenter commented that the scheme of work is now chronological 'vertically, rather than horizontally', which I think is a nice way of putting it.

I've been thinking about how much easier this would make many things - e.g. having done this they would be very well prepared for some of the new GCSE topics such as changing role of the monarchy, but also the implications for classroom displays ('Power', 'War') and parents evenings ('little Billy is doing very well in his understanding of 'Power' but his knowledge of 'Empire and exploration' needs work')
 

 
WINTER - Power
Test
SPRING – War & Society
Test
SPRING –
EMPIRE AND EXPLORATION
Test
SUMMER – Social History
End of year test
Yr 7
The Monarchy 1066 to Present
End by making video
Test on ‘Power’
Norman Conquest to Wars of the Roses
End by making video?
Test on War and society
Roman/Greek Empires?
Columbus/Captain Cook, maps, founding of Empire
Test on Empire/exploration
Ancient/Medieval Leisure
 
End with video/project?

Test on all aspects learned that year
Yr 8
Recap of Year 7 – watch video
Campaigns for vote – Peterloo to Suffragettes
 
End with video/project?
Test on ‘Power’ – covering 7-8
Recap of Year 7
 
English Civil Wars to Napoleonic wars/Waterloo?
 
End with video/project?
Test on War and society – 7 and 8
Recap of Year 7
 
‘High’ Empire – e.g. India, ‘Scramble for Africa’, gaining of Empire after WW1, colonial wars, Dr. Livingstone, Shackleton, Scott?
French/Spanish empires?
Test on Empire/exploration – 7 and 8
Recap of Year 7
 
Tudor/Georgian leisure
 
End with video/project?
Test on all aspects learned that year + previous year
Yr 9
Recap of 7 + 8
 
Rights and freedom in 19/20th century – Holocaust? Nazis? Russia?
Test on ‘Power’ – covering 7-9
Recap of 7 + 8

1st and 2nd World Wars? Cold War? Recent wars Iraq etc?
Test on War and society – 7, 8, and 9
Recap of 7 + 8
End of Empire – decolonization, Falklands, Moon landings, space..?
Rise of ‘Chinese’ Empire? Globalisation?
Test on Empire/exploration
7 8 and 9
Recap of 7 + 8
 
Victorians, music halls, 20th century, film, computer games..?
Test on all aspects learned that year + previous years
 
 

What do you think? Any comments?
 


 
 

A bit about me

"History is that certainty produced at the point where the imperfections of memory meet the inadequacies of documentation.” Julian Barnes

So I tried to start this blog off with a quote about History that made me sound clever and went for the above, which I think sums up pretty nicely some of the difficulties about teaching History.

A bit about me - I teach History in a normal Secondary school in the Cambridgeshire Fens.  The point of this blog is to help me to reflect on some of the lessons I teach,  and to share ideas with other like-minded History teachers about some of the challenges, but also the joy, of teaching a subject that can be amazing, funny, inspiring, but also pretty daunting (especially if you are trying to plan new A-levels, new GCSEs, and new KS3 all at the same time)...

Please do contact me if you want to network - I'm a big believer that History teachers should share as much as possible as to me it seems madness that we all slave away at the same lessons independently instead of sharing more!